Welcome back to the Mets Beat newsletter! Bill Ladson is filling in for Anthony DiComo today. 

NEW YORK -- Benny Agbayani was a fourth outfielder when he played for the Mets from 1998-2001. During his time in the Big Apple, Agbayani had that lunchpail mentality, grinding it out on the field daily. By the time he left New York, Agbayani was a cult hero for Mets fans, having received icon status on Oct. 7, 2000.

It was the 13th inning of Game 3 of the National League Division Series against the Giants at Shea Stadium. The two teams were tied at 2 when Agbayani swung at a 1-0 pitch from left-hander Aaron Fultz and hit the ball over the left-center-field wall to give New York a 3-2 victory and a 2-1 series lead. New York ended up winning the series the next day and advancing to the NL Championship Series against the Cardinals.    

“When we played in 2000, we were like the underdog. We made it all the way to the World Series. No one thought we would be there,” Agbayani said via telephone. “I remember [then-hitting coach] Tom Robson telling me, ‘I think you could end this game right now.’ I just had that confidence. I said, ‘Coach, I’m going to end this right now.’ … I got a pitch to square up and I hit it. Over at Shea Stadium, it was tough to hit a home run in New York. The air is so thick. When the ball went up, I saw [left fielder] Barry [Bonds] running back. I said, ‘Oh, no. Is he going to catch it?’ I saw the fans standing up, and then boom. Home run.”  

The home run proved to be the biggest hit of Agbayani's career. He would last five years in the big leagues, mostly with the Mets, before playing six years with the Chiba Lotte Marines in the Japanese Pacific League.

“I had a great time playing in New York,” Agbayani said. “It still brings chills hearing that crowd. I respected the fans of New York because they always put you in check whenever you needed to be in check. They had the same feeling I had: They wanted me to go out there and win.”         

While his moment in the 2000 NLDS was truly unforgettable, Agbayani loves to talk about his son, Bruin Agbayani, who recently committed to play college baseball for South Carolina starting in 2025. Bruin is currently a shortstop for Mililani High School in Hawaii, and according to perfectgame.com, he is a left-handed hitter with plus bat speed. Benny said his son is better than he was at that age. Bruin’s lefty batting style reminds Benny of Phillies first baseman Bryce Harper, and Bruin would like his defense to be similar to his hero, Mets shortstop Francisco Lindor. 

“He wanted to play in the Southeastern Conference, and he picked South Carolina. Just having him take his game to the next level, I’m very proud of him,” Benny said. “His ultimate goal is to play pro ball. He always asked me why I didn’t name him Benny the Third. I said, ‘We named you Bruin because we want you to fulfill your own shoes, succeed in the game and do it on your own terms.’ I will always be there to support him.

“He is better than me. Growing up, he has been around the game. He has a lot of resources. He has a lot of my friends -- people that could guide him, give him advice. That’s the great part of this game.

“For me, I played this game for a long time. All the friends I made, they came back, and they shared it with my son.”

Darryl Strawberry is the Mets’ all-time career leader in home runs with 252. But he wants to see first baseman Pete Alonso remain a member of the Mets long term and break his record. 

Alonso, who is a free agent after the 2024 season, needs 61 home runs to pass Strawberry. Alonso hit .217 with 46 home runs and 118 RBIs in 2023.  

“I hope it works out well for Pete,” Strawberry said during the news conference to announce his No. 18 will be retired by the Mets on June 1. “He showed that he is capable of playing in New York -- playing under the bright lights and pressure. All the expectations are going to always be there. Once you start putting up big numbers, you are always going to look for more. … He has been productive. 

“I hope [Alonso and the Mets] reach a point where they come together and keep him [in New York]. Let him be the player he has been. Let him break all the records. Records are meant to be broken. Some guys can sit here and don’t want players to break their records. I hope players break my records. That means I’ve done something, and you have done something, too. He has done that. He has performed at that level. You hope and pray they can work it out.”               

On May 16, 1983, Strawberry hit his first Major League home run off which Pirates pitcher?

A. Jim Bibby 
B. Kent Tekulve 
C. Larry McWilliams 
D. Lee Tunnell 

Dwight Gooden wanted to end his playing career with the Mets. After making his way to the Yankees, Cleveland, Tampa Bay and Houston, Gooden called then-Mets GM Steve Phillips and asked for a chance to end his career with the organization that gave him his first chance in the big leagues. But according to Gooden, Phillips told him the team didn’t have any room.

With his uniform No. 16 getting retired on April 14 at Citi Field, Gooden will get a chance to thank the Mets fans for the support over the years.        

“I’m not pointing fingers and I’m not upset or anything,” Gooden said. “I want to make that one last appearance. It won’t be Shea Stadium; it will be Citi Field. I want to stand in front of the Mets [fans] to let them know how special they really are to me.”        

D. Tunnell allowed the home run to Strawberry in the fifth inning during an 11-4 victory over the Pirates. 

To subscribe to Mets Beat, visit this page and mark "Mets Beat" from our newsletter list. Make sure you're following the Mets or that they're checked as your favorite team.

View Online